I had to fight for a vaccine because of my HIV status
Many people with HIV deal with status-based discrimination, especially if they are open about their status. This discrimination manifests even in medical spaces among highly credentialed individuals. For instance, in February, a doctor refused to give me a yellow fever vaccination after I shared my HIV status with her. I had requested a yellow fever vaccination in anticipation of a work trip. On my intake form, I noted that I had an underlying health condition. After handing in the form, the attending nurse asked what my underlying health condition was. “I am living with HIV,” I told her. She responded by explaining that I’d have to speak with the clinic’s medical director because I had AIDS.
I corrected her, repeating that I was living with HIV and explained that I was on the HIV treatment drug Biktarvy, undetectable, physically fit and healthy. Rather than engage with me further, she summoned the medical director who explained, “You cannot have this vaccination because of your health condition.”
Rather than take this doctor at her word, I repeated my undetectable status and referenced numerous studies showing that people with HIV are allowed to receive yellow fever vaccines. As a 2024 study published by the Brazilian Journal of Infectious Diseases noted, “The [yellow fever] vaccine 17DD was safe in [people living with HIV] with CD4 ≥200 cells/µL.” And as I explained to the medical director, yellow fever is endemic in Nigeria—where I was headed in 10 days. Nigeria also has one of the highest HIV rates in the world. And people living with the virus there are vaccinated for yellow fever every day.
When this explanation didn’t work, I remembered something Whitney Irie, PhD, told me about dealing with inappropriate power dynamics among care providers: “Just ask them why,” she said. “Even if you don’t have a question, just say, ‘Why do you think that is?’ or ‘Why do you think this would be the best treatment route for me? Could you explain that to me again?’”
When that didn’t work, I remembered something Whitney Irie, PhD, told me about dealing with inappropriate power dynamics among care providers: “Just ask them why,” she said. “Even if you don’t have a question, just say, ‘Why do you think that is?’ or ‘Why do you think this would be the best treatment route for me? Could you explain that to me again?’”
While employing this technique, I also:
- Showed the medical director articles proving there are no contraindications for receiving a yellow fever vaccination if a person is living with undetectable HIV.
- Retrieved my blood lab results from early January, proving that I am in treatment with Biktarvy and have an undetectable viral load.
- Revealed my credentials as one of the world’s leading HIV journalists.
I even offered to call one of my many PhD-toting colleagues in the HIV field to speak on my behalf. Still, this doctor refused to budge.
I was dealing with a doctor who didn’t like anything I had to tell her for no discernible reason.
Call discrimination by its name
At that point, I remembered something Kathy M. Hiers, CEO of AIDS Alabama, told me in 2023: “When you present arguments that are supported by science—whether it’s around syringe access or Medicaid expansion—I’ve had legislators push the research back in my face and say, ‘I don’t care, I don’t like it.’ In this case, I was dealing with a doctor who, for no discernible reason, disliked everything I told her. Instead of trying to appeal to her humanity or insist that she respect the Hippocratic Oath, I accepted that she had a problem with my HIV status. So, I told her that.
“You’re not giving me this vaccine because I’m living with HIV. It’s discrimination.” She protested that this was untrue and that her clinic had a policy against giving such vaccines to people with HIV. So, I called her bluff. “If you had such a policy, you’d have it listed on your walls. But that would be written discrimination. And it would also mean that you weren’t giving COVID-19 vaccines to people with undetectable or untreated HIV. And that simply isn’t true because our communities have been prioritized for care for COVID-19.”
Finally, worn down by my refusal to give up, the medical director said. “Fine. If you want this vaccination, you have to write a note saying that you won’t hold the clinic, any of our nurses, or me responsible if anything bad happens to you.” Though I disliked her approach. I acquiesced and wrote out the note on the back of my intake form. Before delivering my shot, she told me. “I’ve never encountered anyone with HIV in this situation before.”
“You have,” I countered. “You just didn’t know it because they didn’t tell you their status, because of discrimination like this.”
Hate to say it but HIV stigma is back
In all, what should have been a 15-minute procedure took more than an hour. And though I am programmed to fight for my rights, I shudder to think what would have happened if I hadn’t known that I was correct; if I hadn’t known that there was science to back up my claims; if I hadn’t had access to numerous articles and studies proving the truth behind my words. I have written many articles about racism, bureaucracy and miseducation creating barriers to care, but this was my first time encountering a medical professional who created a barrier with medical misinformation-backed stigma.
Though it is early days yet, I fear that our community will see a rise in people using HIV stigma to deny us care over the next four years of Donald Trump’s presidency. But even as this feels shocking and makes no sense, don’t be confused about what is happening. This behavior is stigma, and it is wrong.
As Bruce Richman, executive director of Prevention Access Campaign said for this article, “Doctors shouldn’t deny care to anyone living with HIV regardless of viral load status. This is illegal, unethical and doesn’t align with the science of U=U or how HIV is transmitted.”
To Richman’s point, everyone living with HIV has a right to care, regardless of their viral load count. If my viral load count had been high and my CD4 count low, this doctor could have explained that the most important thing would be to get me into treatment with an antiretroviral therapy that worked for my system and to ensure that my health was optimized. But I don’t think that care was at the forefront of this medical director’s mind. If it had been, I think she would have listened to me, looked at my medical chart and realized, “This person is undetectable and healthy. There is no reason to deny him a vaccine.”
Use everything you have to fight for your care
Even though I knew that there was no reason to deny me care, I was still flummoxed by the experience and began to ponder how I might advise someone who was facing similar challenges. For advice, I reached out to Joseph Cherabie, MD, MSc, assistant professor at the Division of Infectious Diseases of Washington University in St. Louis. Cherabie said, “Simple answer is you try your best to educate them with the resources that are available through guidelines. And if that doesn’t work, you ask for a referral, which is your right to do as a patient.
“Other countries may have different laws and recommendations,” he added, “but you can always point to the best evidence through the World Health Organization and hope that will convince the person to do what is right and based on best practice.”
After speaking with Richman and Cherabie, I reached out to numerous advocates and health professionals who all agreed that what I experienced was stigmatizing and wrong. Of all the words I heard from these individuals, the greatest source of comfort came from T—a Black woman, activist and long-term survivor who spoke on condition of anonymity because of her work. T explained that my experience mirrors something that women often encounter when seeking vaginal health: gaslighting and arbitrary denial of care.
T said that a former doctor had prescribed her Diflucan, which is used for yeast infections. Women living with HIV are prone to yeast infections. With that in mind, T’s file stated that she could receive the medication whenever she needed it. However, after T’s doctor retired, her new provider told her that he was taking her off Diflucan because, “No one needs to take Diflucan every day," while noting that her file said PRN (pro re nata).
After T explained that this simply meant, “Take as needed,” she said her doctor became testy. “I know he knew what it meant,” T explained. “But he put it out there. So I said, ‘I can show you where it’s not harmful for me to do this.’” After many back and forth discussions—including showing the doctor that there were no contraindications for taking Diflucan while living with HIV—T said she realized that he would never respect her voice or her needs.
“Needless to say, he’s no longer my provider,” T said. ”I feel like if you can’t hear me in that room on this level, then you’re not going to hear the other things I say. Black women living with HIV often go into those rooms and we’re quiet because we think the person with the white coat or the person across from us has all the answers. But we are subject matter experts”—experts in our body and needs.
“I am an expert in my own body,” T continued. “And in my own care. I know what’s going on with me because I pay close attention to me. I know that when anything is off, I can call my provider and tell them. But some providers don’t trust us.” Some doctors will insist that we are wrong even when the science-backed truth is staring at them square in the face.
Looking at our shared experiences and the current state of global chaos, T noted that the refusal to hear our community is why many people with HIV stay quiet when they visit their doctor. The tragedy is that our needs are neglected and if anything bad happens to us, we are blamed because we didn’t speak up.
Reflecting on this conundrum, T recalled that when she started treatment over 30 years ago, “whatever the provider said, I was in agreement with.” The reason? “Because I didn’t know I had the option of not agreeing. I didn’t know that I had the option of saying, ‘If you put me on 17 pills a day, I’m not going to take them.’
“I didn’t know that I had the right to say, ‘Hey, I heard about this medication. Let’s try this before we do that.’”
Speak up for yourself but learn to see the writing on the wall
T’s experience is common. There are many studies showing that people don’t talk to their doctors about their concerns or ask questions when they are concerned. There are numerous reasons why, ranging from embarrassment, fear of dismissal to forgetfulness. Though this is far from a rigorously vetted study on the matter, my experience as a medical journalist has found that many people stay quiet even when they are given the opportunity to ask questions because they feel that their doctors have the final say on their care.
For anyone who finds themself in this category, T said it is possible to learn how to speak up for yourself. She said that she learned by attending training sessions provided by various HIV service and community organizations including SisterLove, AID Atlanta and AIDS Alabama.
T said that things changed for the better when she realized, “I have agency over me. And the best thing I can do is to continue to practice that agency.” That breakthrough proved game changing for her in 2019, when she told her doctor that she wanted to switch from her three-pill-a-day HIV regimen to Biktarvy, a single-tablet daily regimen. After her doctor claimed that Biktarvy was too expensive, T looked at the combined price of her three pills and realized that by switching to Biktarvy, she’d save her insurance $1,500 a month.
I am an expert in my own body,’ T continued. ‘And in my own care. I know what’s going on with me because I pay close attention to me. I know that when anything is off, I can call my provider and tell them. But some providers don’t trust us.
“You’ve got to show these things to people,” T said; help your care providers understand that your decision is right for your health and your insurance plan. “But prior to that,” she added, “I never had the courage to say that to anyone. What you’re saying about providers and their telling you that you shouldn’t do something because of your status—without them having all of the information—I think that’s lazy. And I think people truly do not care about my well-being when they don’t take time to investigate something that I say or something that we’ve discussed.”
When a care provider refuses to take your concerns seriously or provide you the care that you deserve, realize that you can walk away from them. As Dr. Cherabie noted, you can ask for a referral to someone who will listen to you and prioritize your needs. Or as Dr. Irie told me, you can ghost or even fire them—and call your insurance company to file a complaint about why.
Whatever you do, don’t allow any care provider to deny you the care that you need. And if a provider suggests a different option, ask them to use the most up-to-date science to explain why they are making this decision. And even then, remember that you can request a second opinion.
One thing history has taught us is that when chaos is afoot, people with HIV will face increased HIV stigma, even as they are deprived of care. Rather than wait for that to happen, I think everyone should take this opportunity to:
- Breathe.
- Reach out to your care team to make sure they align with your needs.
- Create a checklist with your care team to ensure that you are receiving the best care possible.
- Find a new care team if your current providers fail to meet your needs.
By doing so, you won’t run the risk of being caught off guard for denial of care—be it for a vaccine, yeast infection treatment or switch to a new medication.
Juan Michael Porter II is a former senior editor of TheBody.com and a 2024 International AIDS Society (IAS) Journalism Fellow. He is host of the IAS podcast HIV unmuted.
